Guest Goddess Mary Jo Putney Admits to Another Dead Hero!
Jun 30th 2009
Your Friendly GoddessesGuest Goddesses & On Writing!
Please welcome Mary Jo Putney to Mt. Oly! Mary Jo has been so incredibly kind to offer a signed book from her backlist to one commentor.
Welcome Mary Jo!
It’s great to be in Goddess Land! Because we’ve all been laboring so long in diverse vineyards of romance, I know many of the goddesses already, so it’s Old Home Week here in Olympus.
Today is the official release date of my first straight historical romance in several years, and I have to admit that I’ve reverted to one of my bad writing habits by killing off the hero again. Of course, this is romance—it’s not hard to figure out that my half-Hindu duke may not be as dead as is generally presumed.
Even though my second Regency romance, written over twenty years ago, had a hero who was dying of his Waterloo wounds and a heroine who wanted to be a merry widow, it was only a couple of years ago that I realized just how often my heroes (and more rarely, my heroines) barely survive my attentions. Somewhere off in Character Land, I imagine handsome, honorable studs and strong, compassionate females fleeing when there’s a casting call for my books. But they can’t escape me for long!
Death as a plotting device has a lot of merit because it raises the stakes for the reader. The story is literally a matter of life and death. Lots and lots of writers do it; even Shakespeare is solidly in that pack.
Besides, I adore over the top plot elements—which is why in Loving a Lost Lord, the hero is not only missing and presumed dead, but amnesiac when the heroine drags him up on a shingle beach in the far north of England, barely alive.
Amnesia is a jolly plot element, but also, an intriguing puzzle. What is a person when memory and inhibition are stripped away? What is a man or woman when he or she is no longer constrained by the expectations of others? What emerges then? Does the amnesiac person have the chance to become a truer, more honest self?
I’d like to think so. Certainly that’s what I did with Adam, the Duke of Ashton, who has deliberately concealed the Hindu side of his nature so he can appear to be a proper English gentleman. That works until his near fatal accident and his meeting with a beautiful woman who has reasons of her own to claim him as her husband. At the end, Adam and Mariah have both been through a lot, but they’re grateful that I brought them together. (They’re swearing to keep any offspring out of my dangerous hands, though. )
Historical romance is saturated with false identities, amnesia, switched identical twins, highwaymen in disguise, girls dressed as guys, etc. It’s all good fun, and heaven knows I’ve done more than my share! Loving a Lost Lord is the first of my new Lost Lords series. It should be rather like my Fallen Angels series, but instead of Eton being the bond that holds the heroes together, I invented the Westerfield Academy, a school for “boys of good birth and bad behavior.” The academy was founded by an eccentric duke’s daughter to provide a refuge for aristocratic boys who are square pegs in round holes.
The series will be open ended—I’ve already written the first two books (the second is scheduled for May 2010), and I have characters and general story ideas for several more. And as I look at these future books—presumed death and masquerades and even a pair of identical twins figure prominently. This is obviously what my Muse likes, and she isn’t budging!
How about you as readers? What are your favorite plot devices? The ones you can’t stand? The ones you can’t stand, but you’ll read them anyhow if done by a favorite writer? I’d love to talk about it!
Mary Jo Putney, thanking the Goddesses for letting me visit
74 Comments »
74 Responses to “Guest Goddess Mary Jo Putney Admits to Another Dead Hero!”
Kim on 30 Jun 2009 at 4:59 am #
Good morning everyone!
Mary Jo, welcome to Mt. Oly! We’re so thrilled to have you here. One of my very favorite plots is “cinderella”. I just love it when the heroine is transformed and “saved”.
I can’t think of any that I say “I won’t read that!” because if its one of my favorite authors I’m always willing to trust them to give me a HEA. That’s one thing I’ve found as a reader. You have to trust your authors; that they will deliver a happy ending.
As a reader, what is your favorite plot to read about, Mary Jo?
Sheila on 30 Jun 2009 at 5:00 am #
Hi Mary. I have just finished Loving A Lost Lord and I LOVED IT. Can’t wait for the next one.
Can you give us a clue as to who the H/h are in the second book of the series? My guess is Julia and Randall.
As to your question – there are no story lines I absolutely hate but I wouldn’t read a book set in Roman/Egyptian etc times. And I don’t like paranormals, either although I have been known to read a couple by favourite authors.
Sheila
Oh, I do quite like ’secret babies’ although I know a lot of readers don’t!
TrustMe_2_Forget on 30 Jun 2009 at 5:12 am #
OHHH I love the secret baby plots also Sheila…though I hate it when its drug out for years…I actually like the “suprise” pregnancy plots the best (like they can’t figure why or ~how~ that happend)LOL.
Plots I’m not crazy about are cortesean, I tend to stay away from any books with court intrigue, mostly when taken place in Tudor times, and I really hate TOO many misunderstandings, sure the BIG MIS usually adds to the book, but when they keep crossing wires it drives me NUTS. OH and don’t let me forget the To Stupid To Live heroines, come ON, please give her some brains.
Lisa H on 30 Jun 2009 at 5:31 am #
Hi Mary Jo! Welcome! My favorite plots are unrequieted love, and what I call the Somersby plot. I love when the hero has been in love with the heroine forever and she has no clue. Maybe they even get engaged to other people, but then something happens and, they realized what they want has been there all along. The Somersby plot is where the hero goes away for an extended period of time and returns. But he has changed. Is it truly him or someone who merely looks like him?
Also I love the Cinderella and Beauty and the Beast themes as well. (Die hard Disney fan) I’m sure there are others, but its early!
Sabrina Jeffries on 30 Jun 2009 at 5:56 am #
Welcome, Mary Jo! You already know I’m a huge fan, so I’m running right out to buy your latest!
I love over the top plots, too. I love amnesia, Beauty and the Beast, masquerades, reunion plots, marriage of convenience, and even secret baby stories. Oddly enough, Cinderella stories aren’t really my thing although once in a while, I enjoy a good one. I’m not so keen on the Ugly Duckling plot either, because it always implies that the heroine was not acceptable to the hero when she wasn’t attractive but now is.
Your new series sounds great! I can’t wait to read it.
amy1242 on 30 Jun 2009 at 6:01 am #
Welcome Mary Jo! I love your plots and will pick up your new book!
Trust Me, I’m with you on too many misunderstandings making reading way too stressfull to enjoy. Or when the heroine is a total shrew. In both those cases, by the time the HEA finally comes, I don’t care anymore and in my own head I silently change the ending to fit my own needs. It doesn’t happen often, but sometimes I’ll put the book down before it’s finished because I just can’t read it anymore, and go on to a new one. There’s one author out there, who is very popular, that I just don’t buy anymore. I’ve tried her several times and always want to strangle her hero or heroine. They just don’t fit. No one here, of course. I love all the goddesses and their books.
Becky on 30 Jun 2009 at 6:01 am #
Hi Mary Jo!
My favorite plots involve masqueredes, bad boys who can’t help but fall for the girl, marriages that are in trouble, the plain girl who gets the sexy man, and now I’m going to add in amnesia because that sounds FABULOUS! I can’t stand whiney heroines, however, and sometimes when they guy is a bad boy and he is REALLY bad to her, I get so frustrated when she doesn’t stand up for herself. But…I am a fan of profound apologies and eternal retribution…. And I’m totally with you, TrustMe, about the Too Stupid To Live heroines. I want to shoot them all…
Anyway, thanks for coming, Mary Jo and I look forward to your new series!!!
Susan M on 30 Jun 2009 at 6:12 am #
Hi Mary Jo! My favorites are marriage of convenience, Beauty and the Beast, secret babies, and paranormal. I do not any books that involve spouses cheating on each other or graphic rape scenes. Can’t wait to read your new book!
Louisa Edwards on 30 Jun 2009 at 6:22 am #
Honestly, I love amnesia storylines. Probably the result of too much General Hospital at an impressionable age. But I love the drama! I also adore tortured heroes, secrets from the past, and the head-over-heels hero when combined with oblivious-heroine. There’s not much I won’t read on principle; I’d trust my favorite authors to make just about anything work. I’ve been surprised too many times into loving something I thought I’d hate!
Joy on 30 Jun 2009 at 6:24 am #
My absolute favorite is when friends see each other in a new light and fall in love. I’m not too keen on the hero or heroine falling for the sibling of his/her former spouse.
Pesky on 30 Jun 2009 at 6:31 am #
I like a little intrigue. A little mystery in the past something you have to dig for. (As long as it isn’t something so far out of left field I get left going…huh?) I like when the hero and heroine work together against some odds, when both characters are likeable with a little bit of lack of knowledge of each other that causes you to say “These two should talk, I’m sure they could work it out.” and lo and behold they do. Down to the bone decent men with a touch of wicked and smart compassionate heroines do it for me every time.
OK, I really, really, really hate the TSTL (Too Stupid To Live) heroine. You know the one I’m talking about, Ohhhhhhhhhhhh Reginald come save me! Wait don’t touch me for I am a fair and gentle maiden. ACK! Go ahead touch me because the icky thing over there is out to get me. *SWOON* Oh my, my favorite dress has been defiled. Oh Reginald, treat me like dirt because I deserve it. WAIT! Reginald! Where are you going?
I’m with the people that say if the hero and heroine are too unlikeable I tend to put down the book.
Cail on 30 Jun 2009 at 6:55 am #
a couple of my favorites have girls dressed as boys. i also love the childhood friends live HEA plots. Beauty and the Beast plots are nice too. I’m with Sabrina in that the Cinderella thing doesn’t really do it for me.
I HATE TSTL heroines. please give the girl some brains! i also hate when the author puts stupid devices in the book to keep bringing them together then taking them apart over and over again. it gets old after the first time.
Archer on 30 Jun 2009 at 6:56 am #
I absolutely LOVE your Fallen Angels series. Petals in the Storm made my cry.
Reggie from The Rake and the Reformer is one of my favorite heroes.
I love Beauty and the Beast, marriage of convenience, stories with bickering couples, and gypsies. I also like American heroins since they seem to be able to get away with more. Anything involving Sheikhs and Harams usually turns me off. Although I do smile when I read about something like a Turkish gown or carpet in the story since I’m Turkish
I like strong somewhat bossy heroes, but can’t read anything that sounds like rape.
Archer on 30 Jun 2009 at 7:02 am #
lol Pesky
TrishD on 30 Jun 2009 at 7:23 am #
Good morning all! And welcome Mary Jo, love the topic.
I just love alpha males. The more testosterone running through their veins, the better. Then bring on the woman he just can’t live without and would do anything to protect. The bad boy with a heart of gold that the “one” can bring out makes me melt every time! But, heroine has to be strong too, no wimpy “I can’t do this without you” women need to apply.
I also love the unrequited love plots, especially when it goes both ways.
What do I not like? Gonna have to think on that one.
Claudia Dain on 30 Jun 2009 at 7:35 am #
Mary Jo, welcome!! It’s such a treat having you on the Mt.
It sounds like such a fun series! I can’t wait to get my copy LOVING A LOST LORD.
I’m a misfit in the world of Romance in that I don’t like any of the fairy tale tropes because I feel like I know the whole story in advance. I love arranged marriages, fish out of water, enemies to lovers, and redemption stories. I’m with the rest of the world in not enjoying TSTL characters, though if they make one or two mistakes in judgment, that’s okay. We all do that!
Karen Hawkins on 30 Jun 2009 at 7:39 am #
YAH! MARY JO PUTNEY IS HERE! I’m a huuuuge fan and am SO excited to hear about the new series!
I love series. I love to see couples from previous books as they progress a little through their lives, and you get these glimpses in series books.
I guess my favorite stories are best friends who fall in love, the Ugly Duckling (because I think we’ve all felt like that once in a while), wrong identity stories (where one character is mistaken for another person), plus I’m a sucker for highwayman and pirate stories, too. Oh, heck, I pretty much love them all except perhaps amnesia stories. Those don’t always click with me.
Mary Jo, I’m looking forward to getting your newest! It sounds WONDERFUL like so many of your books!
Mary Jo on 30 Jun 2009 at 7:44 am #
What a lovely lot of larks are here on Olympus! I’m more of a slow-starting owl in the mornings, but it’s fun to sign on and see so many comments–and some of you have even read and enjoyed Loving a Lost Lord! (It’s okay if you read and didn’t enjoy–we all have different tastes. But on the whole, I’d rather not know before my second cup of coffee.
)
For those who thought Randall is the next hero–you’re right. I love Will Masterson, but I’m sending him back to the Peninsula during the second book while his story quietly matures. We’ll see more of Kirkland next time, but his story is also in the distance.
I see that the whole range of romance tastes is well represented here! A particular pet hate of mine is the powerful hero who falls for a woman, then destroys her life so she won’t have any choice but to accept him. Such men should be shot.
I like a “transformation” scene when the heroine gets some great clothes and all of a sudden looks terrific, but I invariably use it when she’s insecure about her looks. The hero already knows what a special and beautiful person she is, but she needs convincing.
I think Zeus is shutting me down for the moment. More later!
nancyg on 30 Jun 2009 at 7:48 am #
Good morning, Mary! Congratulations on your latest release! Huge fan here – will be making a trip to Barnes & Noble later today – woo hoo!!
I’ll pretty much swallow any plot device if it’s written well (no worries on your front!). However, I *do* like the Cinderella theme – Julia Quinn had a Bridgerton book that was done very well.
Not a big fan of Beauty & the Beast. I am a fan of the wounded hero – Suzanne Enoch’s England’s Perfect Hero contains my favorite tortured hero… injuries, anmesia, war wounds, emotional scars – just don’t let them lose their “Alpha” status.
I like the tomboy-at-heart heroines. My favorites are the ones that reject suitors waiting for their “one & only” to come to them. I do not like excessive foul language in the bedroom, though. That’s a turn-off, turn-the-page, ruin the book for me, especially in Regency/historical novels.
I loathe books written in 1st person unless it’s an autobiography.
Sorry – opinionated reader here!
freshechelle on 30 Jun 2009 at 7:51 am #
Hi Mary Jo – I’ll be handing out at Barnes and Noble later to pick up your new book. Haven’t read your work yet but your description has sold me.
I’m game for most plots but I get frustrated by the misunderstanding late in the book that feels like thw author was short on pages. Just finished a non-goddess contemporary that really lacked the “will they, won’t they” vibe so some last minute weak tension was slapped in. It felt so choppy.
Mary Jo on 30 Jun 2009 at 7:52 am #
I see several comments have appeared while I was writing a reply. What a fun group you are here! And clearly we’re all romance lovers to the marrow.
Claudia, the marriage of convenience story is so central to historical romance because such things really did happen, and they truly force the characters to DEAL with each other! This is endlessly interesting–one man, one woman, one bed, effectively forever. Make it work or ELSE!
My editor, the magnificent Kate Duffy, has loved both of the books I’ve given her, but she said that the second book surprised her more because an amnesia story has a certain natural arc, and my second book didn’t/ We’re talking about a title for the second now, and I’d like to hear your thoughts.
LOVING A LOST LADY actually fits the story beautifully, but is it too much like the first title? Confusing or silly? How about MARRY IN HASTE…..?
Karen–SO true that we’ve all felt like the Ugly Duckling. That’s why I love transformations scenes, when the swan feathers appear.
I think I’ve said enough for now….
Madeline Hunter on 30 Jun 2009 at 8:03 am #
Hi, Mary Jo!
So glad to have you visit! You are the first writer I glommed.
I am open to any plot device if it is handled well, but I am a real sucker for marriage of convenience stories and arranged marriage stories. I am okay with girl dressed as boy if it is plausible, which is hard to do. There are some devices I’m not wild about, but I will read them if it is one of my favorite authors because I know they will make it work, and the device will not lead to eye-rolling on my part. I will put up with almost anything in a female character even if she annoys me, but I am sort of picky about the guys. I guess that the only plot device that truly irritates me is when a character has a moment of truth and transforms to the point of actually being a different character. I’m like, hey, I don’t care if he is reformed if he is a stranger now.
Madeline Hunter on 30 Jun 2009 at 8:04 am #
I like the second title better. How about Married in Haste?
TrishD on 30 Jun 2009 at 8:05 am #
Nancy… I agree with you…love the wounded hero! The hero who thinks he’s “ruined” and no good for the one he loves. Yet, not matter how hard he tries he just can’t give her up.
Madeline Hunter on 30 Jun 2009 at 8:07 am #
There are some plot devices that aren’t used much anymore, and that I sort of miss. It may be a p.c. thing. I like woman as captive stories. The dynamics are usually interesting, and the conflict is undeniable. The guys are always alpha. Throw in that she is often in a new environment or culture, not her own comfortable world, so there is the fish out of water aspect—- those stories usually have me hooked from the get-go.
Rachel Gibson on 30 Jun 2009 at 8:09 am #
Welcome Mary Jo,
My favorite plots are Cinderella, ugly duckling, and secret baby. As for amnesia, I’m skeptical of anyone who claims amnesia.
rachelg
JudyPatooty on 30 Jun 2009 at 8:26 am #
Welcome to Mt. Oly, Mary Jo! I’m very much looking forward to reading your latest!
I can’t think of any particular plots that I can’t stand. If a book is well-written it doesn’t particularly matter to me.
My favorite plots are the same as so many others have mentioned. Cinderella and Beauty & the Beast I think I like the best. I also like “a second chance at love” stories, where the hero and heroine are older than the average. Probably because I’m older than the average!
Nicole Jordan on 30 Jun 2009 at 8:27 am #
Woohoo, Mary Jo! Welcome!!! As you know, you’re one of my all-time favorite romance authors so I’m thrilled to have you as a guest goddess.
I have LALL in my hot little hands and can’t wait to dive in as soon as I meet my deadline. Lost Lords is such a great premise for a series. As for titles, I hate trying to come up with them so I don’t envy you.
Love Cinderella, Beauty and the Beast, Ugly Duckling, Taming of the Shrew, Bad Boys, there are lots.
So a question for you, Mary Jo? After writing so many wonderful romances, how are you able to offer fresh stories for your readers, which you always do?
Kat on 30 Jun 2009 at 8:28 am #
Wow — I’m late to the party this morning! Welcome Mary Jo — your new book looks fantastic, I can’t wait to pick it up.
I don’t think I have a favorite plot, but I like the “special school” idea — kinda like the “School for Heiresses” from Sabrina’s books — those are yummy too. I think I prefer regency and historicals, but I read almost anything I can get my little fingers on. I’m not such a big fan of paranormals unless it’s truly convincing. I think I’d like a harem story though. I really like exotic men. But a Mr. Darcy can be done well too. . .hmmm.
Tanya on 30 Jun 2009 at 9:04 am #
What are your favorite plot devices?
I love plots that involve twins! My favorite though is the VERY bad boy ‘turned’good (but not too good)! Lots of testosterone… Yummy!
The ones you can’t stand?
Secret Babies… Naiveté’ is one thing… Really?! You don’t know how you made a baby?! Really?!
The ones you can’t stand, but you’ll read them anyhow if done by a favorite writer? I’m not a huge fan of the heroine dressed as a man/boy… Although I have been known to read them and even enjoy them when done by my favorites. (A good example is Eloisa James’ Duchess by Night).
Suzanne Enoch on 30 Jun 2009 at 9:06 am #
Welcome, Mary Jo!!
I love the amnesia plots! I can’t believe I haven’t written one yet. Unless I have, and I’ve forgotten about it. Hm. *g*
Your new series sounds fab! Isn’t it just the best, starting out a new series, getting to know everybody, setting up for the next stories, etc? (And can you tell that’s where I am right now?)
Mary Jo on 30 Jun 2009 at 9:14 am #
Madeline–MARRIED IN HASTE also works, but perhaps “Marry in haste” more easily brings “repent at leisure” to mind. Waiting to hear what the all powerful “Sales” has to say, of course.
I’m not at all fond of the captivity story, which is first cousin of the “I lust for you so I’ll destroy your life if your reject me” plot line. There’s no denying the power inherent in that conflict, though. And the fish out of water is always fun, too.
Rachel–you’re right that amnesia is something of a stretch and certainly is shamelessly manipulated by authors like me. But one of our occasional guests over at our Word Wenches blog is Dr. Josh King, son of Susan Fraser King, who answers medical questions about the past. I asked him about amnesia, and he basically said that the mind is so complicated that one can get away with almost anything, which assuages my conscience a little. Of course there also fugue states, where the mind is avoiding an unacceptable reality, but I can’t say that in a historical….
Mary Jo on 30 Jun 2009 at 9:27 am #
Good to see you here, Nicole! I’m not sure I -always- come up with completely fresh plots, but I did take something of a hiatus from straight historical romance for several years when I could feel burnout lurking. Now I’m back and juggling old elements into hopefully fresh ways!
**I love the amnesia plots! I can’t believe I haven’t written one yet. Unless I have, and I’ve forgotten about it. Hm. *g***
LOL, Suzanne! I’ve done three, and might have done more if I thought I could get away with it. *g* It sounds like you’re having great fun spinning your masterly web for a new series!
I’m off to lunch with a friend now, but will be back later!
Rachel Gibson on 30 Jun 2009 at 9:29 am #
Mary Jo
I guess I have a hard time buying it is because I raised three children who had really convenient amnesia. Also, once I saw a woman on Oprah who claimed to have amnesia. Then her husband joined her on stage, and I took one look at him and knew I’d claim amnesia too.
Conversely, one of my favorite all time movies is Regarding Henry.
Calila on 30 Jun 2009 at 9:31 am #
I love marriage of convience, cinderella,beauty and the beast, bad boys, wounded heros, plain jane wins the sexy hero, falling for the best friend’s sibling, and Ugly duckling(really only works if the hero was intrigied before the makeover otherwise it seems shallow).
Not really fond of but can enjoy if done right kidnappings and girl in disguise.
Really really don’t like are secret baby and sheihks or any variation.
I agree about the too stupid to live heroines and the powerful men who abuse it.
Looks like I like more that I hate, LOL.
Pesky on 30 Jun 2009 at 9:47 am #
LOL Rachel, convenient amnesia. Kinda like the old excuse “I’m sorry I missed that.” which translates to “Oh I heard you fine, I am however ignoring you.”
I love Regarding Henry, but I didn’t take it as an amnesia story, probably because he didn’t get all his memory back, and what he did he just said “well, I’m not that person any more so…bye”. I was more concentrated on the SOB personality so broken down that he was willing to eat something he hated because someone told him he should. The tobasco sauce in the eggs to get him to say “No, I don’t like this.” was classic. The scene at the end always has me tearing up, where he walks in and says “I’m sorry, I missed so much time with my daughter when she was growing up, I don’t want to miss a moment more.” *sniffle, sniffle*
So…in conclusion, I’m good with amnesia plot but if you’re not it’s totaly understandable you like Regarding Henry.
BTW heading out to get my Tuesday releases. 
NinaP on 30 Jun 2009 at 10:02 am #
Hi Mary Jo!! Great post. My favorite MJP plot devices are death and wounded heroes, China Bride being the favorite combo. Plot devices I can’t stand are “whose baby is it?” and “heroine sans backbone.”
Cail on 30 Jun 2009 at 10:05 am #
Karen, How could i have forgotten to mention Pirate Stories?! That’s what got me hooked on romance novels in the first place. Although, I do wish that so many of them weren’t captive stories.
Regarding girl dressed as boy, there are some EXCELLENT books done like this. Captain Jack’s Woman (by Stephanie Laurens) and of course, Lady Rogue by our own Suzie Enoch are excellent examples of a very well done book of this style.
England’s Perfect Hero is my favorite wounded hero book. My mom has had my copy for far too long. I’ve been craving a re-read.
I’m trying to remember the amnesia books I’ve read- but ironically, i’m blanking.
Mary Jo- which of your books would you count as your favorite?
Beth C. on 30 Jun 2009 at 10:07 am #
I have to say I like to read Love Triangles. Phantom of the Opera and Sabrina (along with In My Wildest Dreams by Christina Dodd) are my favorite stories.
Sabrina Jeffries on 30 Jun 2009 at 10:24 am #
Tanya, when you say “secret baby” stories, you do realize that some of us are talking about romances where the hero doesn’t know he fathered a child because the heroine didn’t tell him. I don’t think the women don’t know they’re pregnant–they just choose not to let the father know. That’s the kind of secret baby story *I* like.
I’m not fond of the love triangle stories myself, but I do LOVE captive stories (Madeline, you and I are definitely on the same page there). The problem is they’re hard to do so that I really feel that the hero/heroine are choosing each other. I read one recently, though, that I loved–Monica Burn’s Kismet. It’s one of those sheikh books though, so some of you won’t like it, but I love sheikh books. I love heroes of mixed blood or from other cultures, too, so I’m thrilled that this guy is half-Indian!
nancyg on 30 Jun 2009 at 10:24 am #
MaryJo –
stopped off at Barnes & Noble on my way back from the gym in my grubby, post-beat-down clothes to pick up a copy of your book – the cover is BEAUTIFUL!! They had you right in front next to Christine Feehan’s new release.
Saving it for this weekend…if my kids will leave me alone…can’t wait to sink my teeth into it (figuratively speaking, of course!).
nancyg on 30 Jun 2009 at 11:22 am #
by the way, just saw on my e-alert that you’re chatting tomorrow night at Writerspace??
cheryl c. on 30 Jun 2009 at 12:10 pm #
Favorite plots: beauty and the beast, Cinderella, amnesia, mail-order brides, marriages of convenience, rescues, secretly vulnerable Alpha males, enemies to lovers, children as matchmakers, second chances, and gee, I could go on and on!
I am not crazy about love triangles because I know someone is bound to get hurt in the end. I like for my romance novels to end totally happy!
Archer on 30 Jun 2009 at 12:18 pm #
Can’t believe I also forgot pirates.
SheridanLA on 30 Jun 2009 at 12:27 pm #
Hi, Mary Jo!
plot devices… I am not so much into the “secret babies”.. it is done well sometimes, but most of the time it comes of as “how the hell do I wrap this up? OH!! John just HAPPENS to be the secret love child of Edward… problem solved!”
I also get a bit annoyed with characters using a rather lame excuse to keep a secret/on a fruitless “quest” or something else where it gets ridiculous and you just want to yell at them for being so stupid or pigheaded.
I think with everything, there are good examples of things and bad…. talented writers can make a lot of things work where others could not.
Mary Jo on 30 Jun 2009 at 2:03 pm #
**I guess I have a hard time buying it is because I raised three children who had really convenient amnesia. Also, once I saw a woman on Oprah who claimed to have amnesia. Then her husband joined her on stage, and I took one look at him and knew I’d claim amnesia too**
LOL, Rachel! Given that you’ve been exposed to “situational” or possibly “chore related” amnesia, I don’t blame you for being suspicious. And there are definitely things we’d LIKE to forget, but usually our memories are not so cooperative. *g*
Nancy, given the shape my hero is in when he first appears, grubby gym clothes are about right. *g*
I’m another who can’t stand the TSTL heroine. I don’t want heroes who are stupid either, of course, but one can expect a certain amount of cluelessness from men. *g* I expect more of my heroines.
Nicole Jordan on 30 Jun 2009 at 2:12 pm #
Mary Jo, you may regularly use tried-and-true, classic romance plots, but you always make them fresh and special! What was it Publisher’s Weekly just said in their review for LOVING A LOST LORD?
“The enchanting first Lost Lords novel confirms bestseller Putney as a major force in historical romance…. Entrancing characters and a superb plot line catapult this tale into stand-alone status.”
I’d say that’s pretty high praise!
LauraR on 30 Jun 2009 at 2:43 pm #
Welcome Mary Jo!
I read the excerpt on your site the other day and can’t wait to pick it up. As others have said I’ll read most any plot if it’s well written but the wife-beaters or rape make me cringe. I don’t care if the SOB gets what he deserves in the end.
Mary Jo on 30 Jun 2009 at 3:18 pm #
Ooooh, thanks for quoting the Publishers Weekly review, Nicole! The book got starred reviews in PW and Library Journal as well as a Top Pick at RT, but naturally modesty forbid me to mention that. *g*
Sabrina, I also love characters of mixed blood because the ‘between two worlds’ scenario is a good metaphor for feeling like an outsider, which most of us can relate to. However, I’ve actually done it more often with heroines than heroes. No particular reason, it’s just worked out that way. (Half Mohawk heroine in England, Scottish-Chinese heroine, half-Hindu duke…) It’s a good character arc for such characters to come to terms with themselves, because self-acceptance is the beginning of wholeness. And it’s very romantic to have the partner love the person for what is unique and different. It’s All Good.
Mari on 30 Jun 2009 at 3:47 pm #
Favorites are: secret babies, H/h separated for years and the H doesn’t know about the babies existence until he finds out in a shocking way, shy heroines that get a backbone, Alpha Males, “bastard” Heroes who’s fathers are noblemen that scorned them, light paranormal (such as a ghost or a H/h or supporting character that is psychic) but all other elements non-paranormal, ugly ducklings that turn into swans (like formerly overweight H or h), inexperienced or virgin H or h, H/h hate each other then slowly realize it’s because they really love each other and don’t want to admit it, stranded on an island alone, scarred hero
Not favorites: When it is completely obvious to everybody but the H/h who the villian is, when the villian is an experienced or promiscuous woman and/or a gay man that wants the hero to himself, courtesans who act like they have never seen a you-know-what appendage before, relationships that are consummated too quickly or not until the last page, historicals with heroines that act and speak as though they are in the 21st century, heroes that treat the heroine like garbage until they have an aha moment in the last 20 pages
dbrown3400 on 30 Jun 2009 at 4:19 pm #
Hi Mary Jo. Can’t wait to read LOVING A LOST LORD. It’s a “Duke” book and they are my favorite. I’ll overlook other obvious flaws if the story involves a duke. LOL Other plots I enjoy are girl disguised as boy, my favorite being GENTLE ROGUE by Johanna Lindsey; Beauty and the Beast; and Ugly Duckling.
The one that irritates me the most is an unsavory member of the family who keeps the pair apart until the end of the book. I guess I like the couple to have more “together” time. Or an event that keeps them apart for ten years. The TSTL heroine will lose me every time.
TrustMe_2_Forget on 30 Jun 2009 at 4:31 pm #
I forgot how much I love a bad boy (or former villian) turned hero…I’m an absolute sucker for pirates, cowboys and vikings or most anything Americana…can’t remember the last “new release” I’ve read that took place during the Revolutionary or Civil War.
and I hate hate hate when thoughout the book the hero is a commoner but by the end inheirits a dukedom or some other aristocratic estate.
Jamie on 30 Jun 2009 at 4:50 pm #
I think the only stories I DON’T like are those where there is more sex than story and the TSTL heroine, who is not only stupid, but plays on the heart strings of the hero. They are so concerned about themselves and don’t realize that their hero is bending over backwards to please them.
The ones I LOVE are the rakes, rogues ones. I like the hero and heroine to be friends as well as lovers. I like when the heroine is a bookish spinster (partly because I’m a bookish spinster). Cinderella stories are good with having either the heroine or hero be Cinderella. The Beauty and the beast ones are always good – the beast usually has a huge heart and I’m a sucker for a hero with a big heart. People have talked about the ugly duckling stories. Personally I like the hero to love the ugly duckling for who she is and doesn’t want her to change unless she wants to.
The one I love the best is those couples who have a past history together. They have been parted and are together again. These are the best because you can put in the secret child, making up for past wrongs and add the hero with a wounded soul.
Louisa Cornell on 30 Jun 2009 at 5:50 pm #
Mary Jo Putney! Squeeee! Huge fan girl moment here! I love your books! The China Bride is one of my favorites.
I tend to agree that just about any plot device will do if it is in the hands of one of my favorite authors.
I have a real soft spot for Beauty and the Beast stories. I love heroines who are considered too smart, too opinionated or not the perfect English rose. I love heroes who are honorable, funny and sexy as the devil.
I don’t like stupid heroines and I don’t like heroines who are CONSTANTLY sniping at the hero. Give the poor guy a break! He’s a HERO!
I had to laugh at characters running for the hills when the casting call goes out for your books. You really do have a knack for torturing your characters and I wouldn’t want it any other way!
Mary Jo on 30 Jun 2009 at 7:03 pm #
dbrown, LOL about your penchant for dukes. I think there are way too may of them running around fictional Regency England, but this time, the hero needed to be a duke. I’m glad you approve. *g* I also share your distaste for people who maliciiously interfere with the central relationship, though it admittedly produces conflict.
Louisa, our tastes seem to be very similar. which is probably why you enjoy my stories. I like the comment by – Paula Poundstone?–that it’s good to picka man with a pierced ear because he’s suffered pain and bought jewelry, both good qualifications for hero-ness. *g*
It’s so much fun to hear what everyone likes and dislikes! But now I’m going to wind this up because I need to write a public service announcement, and it will take more words.
Mary Jo on 30 Jun 2009 at 7:10 pm #
Here’s the public service announcement: this afternoon my doctor called to say that she just got blood test results back and I have acute Lyme disease. This is actually GOOD news, because acute means that the infection just happened and it should be easily knocked out by a course of antibiotics. I’ve already started this.
But chronic Lyme can horrendous, and particularly along the Eastern seaboard, we need to be wary. Because I did NOT have any of the obvious symptoms of Lyme. No raised bull’s eye, no rash, no fever, too early for aching joints. Plus, I am SO not the outdoor type–walking across the back of the house to turn on water so I can water my deck flowers is as outdoorsy as I get. Plus, it’s been a cool spring, and I haven’t been outside once when I wasn’t wearing long pants. But the house backs up to woods, deers cruise through there, and that did it.
What I did have was an itchy bite that might have been from a spider, surrounded by a red area in a perfect 5″ circle. Not swollen, but distinctly red. (Con’t below)
Mary Jo on 30 Jun 2009 at 7:15 pm #
Lyme disease con’t:
The red circle on my leg never got acute, but it spread and I felt little tingles and bruise-like soreness. I’m quite sure that I didn’t have a tick on my calf in a very visible spot for one or two days, which it is supposed to take to get infected. This surely was quicker. So there was much that was not typical.
But I decided to consult my lovely internist, and her brows went up when I mentioned the red circle. She said the bull’s eye often didn’t appear, and she sent me right upstairs to the blood lab to get tested. The results came today, and the infection is already being blasted.
So–if you live anywhere near the Lyme zone–Connecticut is ground zero, but anywhere in the east–PAY ATTENTION to any odd bites even if they don’t fit the pattern. Listen to your body. Though I had no acute symptoms, I *knew* something was wrong. If it had turned out to be a spider bite–I wouldn’t have been embarrassed to have pursued the matter. Since it -is- Lyme–I’m feeling very proud of myself for being alert. Please–you do the same.
Jamie on 30 Jun 2009 at 8:05 pm #
Mary Jo, I got Lyme disease one year and caught the bulls eye. I was able to be completely recovered by it because I got it in it’s early stages. Since you got it early, you will be Lyme free too.
Although it takes all the fun out of gardening. That is how I got it. There were deer ticks near where I had my garden. Now, I let my bro-in-law’s men do the gardening.
You book looks really good, I intend to add it to my reading list. Thanks for stopping by today!
Becky on 30 Jun 2009 at 8:15 pm #
Oh, Nicole, I LOVE Taming of the Shrew stories! I can’t believe I forgot that one!
And Mary Jo, hurray for acute stage and for knowing what it is!!!
Mary Jo on 30 Jun 2009 at 8:34 pm #
Jamie, thanks for the reassurance that quick treatment really does do the job! I’m sorry it’s interfered with your gardening. I find it mildly alarming that I got zapped with so little exposure, but as long as I found it, all is cool.
>>I love heroes who are honorable, funny and sexy as the devil. >>
Funny is vital! A shared sense of humor is such a powerful bond. Georgette Heyer knew that well.
Nicole Jordan on 30 Jun 2009 at 10:11 pm #
Thank heavens you caught it so quickly, Mary Jo. I know two people who didn’t and they have serious life-long complications.
And thanks so much for visiting and sharing with us today. You’ll always be a goddess in my book, wherever you are!
Jennifer Myrna on 30 Jun 2009 at 10:57 pm #
Ms. Putney,
My favorite books by you also contain my favorite plot lines (surprised? lol). I’ve mentioned it (probably way too many times), but Angel Rogue is probably my favorite romance novel hands down. I love-love-love Robin. Why? He’s a tortured soul but the absolute best of men. What he did for Rafe and Margot was amazing. So… I like the tortured (emotionally) hero.
I also loved Michael from Shattered Rainbows (who wouldn’t!!!). While I admit to thinking “the villain” (don’t want to give it away to anyone who hasn’t read it) was a little over the top, the rest of the book was so touching. Your descriptions of Waterloo, the way that Catherine nursed him. Ah, he was the emotionally AND physically injured person.
River of Fire holds a special place in my heart because of the amazing way that you conveyed the rush of artistic/creative “fever”. It was a fun story, and kept me captivated. So I like the historical and factual plot-lines, too.
Uncommon Vows… I did NOT expect to like. But I did. Adrian was emotionally and physically scarred, and he was tortured by his own actions as well. The amnesia, which could have been SO cliche, was perfect for the book. Cont!
Jennifer Myrna on 30 Jun 2009 at 11:06 pm #
I guess I also like the “redemption” plot line.
The Rake (aka The Rake and The Reformer) was the first of your books that I read, and Reggie was just plain wonderful. Allie, however, is what sold the book. She was emotionally fragile in so many ways, but was the epitome of a strong, assertive, yet time-frame appropriate, heroine. Merry and Julian’s romance was great. So, was Desdemona and Giles! So I guess I should say that I love the sub-romance plotline, AND the very strong heroine plotline.
What I particularly love about YOUR books, more than most other authors, is that you so eloquently convey the reasons WHY the characters love eachother. So often in romances we are simply TOLD that they are in love, but are never shown the process. You have never failed to deliver that… except once.
Which leads to my dirty little secret. You have one book that I truly disliked. Just one, though! There’s only one other one I didn’t care for (The Bargain wasn’t high on my favorites list). But the one I hated? Dearly Beloved. It had several plot devices I truly dislike (rape, indifferent hero — he ignored his wife for years, and a heroine I absolutely could not relate to). Cont!
Jennifer Myrna on 30 Jun 2009 at 11:10 pm #
Sorry, this should be the last one! lol
I believe I’ve now read all of your books but the contemporaries (The Lost Lord is waiting for tomorrow when the children can play video games while I read!), but only because I’m not that fond of contemporaries (although I do own them!). While your paranormals were still wonderful, they didn’t seem to be your “voice” if that makes sense.
Finally, I’m sorry you have Lyme disease, but very glad it was caught early. I caught it in 1998, and it played havoc with my immune system, leading to other problems. BUT, since caught early, you should be fine, with no lasting effects.
And while I have a comment for Ms. Hunter, and for Ms. Jeffries, I won’t hijack your thread any more.
Thanks for listening!
Sabrina Jeffries on 01 Jul 2009 at 2:36 am #
Jennifer, that just goes to show how every reader is different. Dearly Beloved is one of my favorites!! I also loved River of Fire, along with you, and really loved the whole Silk trilogy, especially Silk and Shadows.
Jennifer Myrna on 01 Jul 2009 at 6:53 am #
Ms. Jeffries,
Silk and Shadows is one of my favorites as well, with Mikahl being definitely in the top 5 favorite heroes ever. It is so hard to rate! Robin is always #1 for me, but between Michael, Mikahl, Nicholas, and Lucien — not to mention Reggie and Stephen and Ian and Ross and Kenneth and Adrian, etc. etc…. I can’t decide, and so many are favorites! lol I have to admit that Rafe never makes it (which is probably because of Robin, in all fairness), but I did like him better in Angel Rogue — probably because I knew Robin was getting a happily ever after. I know I tend to have “opposite” tastes as some — for instance, The Wild Child was one I really enjoyed, but some people I’ve talked to didn’t care for it. *shrug* If the only book I can say that I didn’t like is Dearly Beloved, than I can accept that.
Only taking a few moments away from reading to comment, because I was curious if there was a response.
Back to go find out if I have room in my heart for Adam, too. Or, rather, another Adam, as that’s my husband’s name as well.
Mary Jo on 01 Jul 2009 at 7:52 am #
Jennifer Myrna, we seem to be mostly on the same page! I think of Dearly Beloved as my “subversion of the rape fantasy” novel. I’m always glad when readers have different favorites. (Thanks, Sabrina!) How sad it would be if everyone agreed that one particular book is the best, and all the others are inferior.
FWIW, Robin in Angel Rogue is the one closest to my SO–it’s the sense of humor.
A friend in Connecticut tells me that where she lives, ground zero for Lyme, getting infected is practically a rite of passage. *g* Fortunately, since the disease is much better known that it used to be, it’s much more quickly diagnosed these days.
Off for now–
MJP
Jennifer Myrna on 01 Jul 2009 at 10:01 am #
Ms. Putney,
I’ve never really gotten to just “chat” with authors about their works, so it’s been a treat!
How wonderful for you to have a person like Robin in your life! In overall personality, my Adam is more like Ross; a bit scholarly, almost a “nerd”, but capable, kind and understanding. But in many ways, especially in wit, humor, and outlook on life, he is like Robin. Though I think in the ways that are most significant, *I* am like Robin. lol I was and am the blacksheep/scapegrace of my family, and my Adam was my saving grace (much like Maxie was to Robin). I guess you could say that the reason I adore his character so much is because I relate to him on many different levels.
Rarely do I associate “inferior” to a work that isn’t necessarily my favorite. While I didn’t like Dearly Beloved, it was no less an excellent piece of writing than any other of your works. It just wasn’t the type of book I like. I greatly admire stepping outside one’s normal comfort zones, I just don’t think it worked in this case.
Oh how I hate looking back at my prior comments and seeing typos. lol
Your friend is right about lyme and rites of passage. Shame, but true.
Patricia Rice on 01 Jul 2009 at 10:18 am #
Well shucks, looks like I missed the party by a day. Story of my life. But I kind of like taking a seat in the corner behind the palm and watching the fun, so this works for me. “G”
Waving hi at people I haven’t seen since last year, hoping to see you at national!
Tanya on 01 Jul 2009 at 2:25 pm #
Sabrina – I just saw what you wrote about “secret babies” and I have to say I’m laughing at myself! I did read a book some time back where the heroine really couldn’t figure out how she got pregnant… I have to say I feel relieved that’s not what you all meant, but also pretty sheepish ’cause I couldn’t figure out why so many people were saying they liked stories like that!!!
Mary Jo on 01 Jul 2009 at 2:34 pm #
Jennifer, if your Adam is rather like my Ross, I’d like the meet him. *g* It is fun to chat about the books, isn’t it?
Hi, Pat! This is a fun blog, isn’t it?
Tal on 01 Jul 2009 at 4:23 pm #
I really enjoy the plain shy, or beauty and the beast plots.. or wounded … for some reason the always have strong emotion… I love that…I love all historicals really any plot can be enjoyable as long as the characters engage you..
I can;t get into the 18 yrs. olds. I know its a time thing.. but as soon as I see 18.. my mind shuts down..
Tal
Sabrina Jeffries on 01 Jul 2009 at 7:03 pm #
LOL, Tanya! Glad we could clear that up for you. No wonder you had trouble with people liking those stories!
Jennifer Myrna on 01 Jul 2009 at 7:53 pm #
Ms. Putney,
I finished Loving a Lost Lord this evening. While it’s not going to oust Angel Rogue, Shattered Rainbows, or Silk and Shadows as some of your best work (in my not-quite-so-humble opinion), it was a fun read and I look forward to the next in the series.
I wanted to add, also (especially after reading this), how much I appreciate how well you include homosexual characters in your books. They are never the “villains” as they are in other works (Sally Mackenzie, I’m talking to you! lol), and the characters are as well developed as any main or side characters would otherwise be. It’s not common, but it is appreciated.
I think everyone should meet my Adam. He’s funny, sweet, and a born diplomat. Where I lack tact, he makes up for it in abundance.